Yesterday, a few Dalhousie architecture students erected a sign proclaiming that they were going to build a Walmart on the site of the old Halifax infirmary. While this was a hoax concocted to study people’s reactions, the notion of bringing a big-box store to the downtown area shouldn’t be dismissed so quickly.
First off, anything has to look better than the mess of the old infirmary. It is an eyesore for to anyone who has to spend any time in that part of Halifax. The space is going to waste, and anything would be an improvement.
Secondly, a Walmart in downtown would definitely bring consumers in who wouldn’t normally frequent the neighborhood. This is not to say that it would take business away from the stores on Spring Garden Rd. On the contrary: many of the Spring Garden businesses cater to a certain clientele that probably wouldn’t be able to find what they’re looking for at other stores, especially at Walmart. Furthermore, these businesses might benefit from some spillover spending brought on by people shopping at Walmart, so they might have MORE money coming in. In a sense, it would have the same effect as Walmart has had at Penhorn, being the “anchor store” in the downtown area, attracting traffic, who then stay to eat at the numerous restaurants, or to catch a movie at Park Lane, for example.
Lastly, if people are concerned about “the crowd” that a Walmart might attract (whatever that means), it can’t be any worse than the homeless people who currently infest the downtown area. What more, it might just give some of those an employment opportunity they wouldn’t otherwise have had!
There are downsides, though: some smaller, generic businesses would suffer, and inevitably close down. Also, Walmart doesn’t really fit in with downtown’s “look” (you don’t find one in downtown TO or Montreal, you’ll find more upscale retailers like Sears or Eaton’s). And finally, it would definitely increase traffic on the already congested downtown streets.
Of course, it could never happen now. Big-box stores don’t have a place in downtown Halifax (where are you, Woolco?). It definitely was an eye-opener, though, especially to those who couldn’t catch on to the fact that it was a hoax. Honestly, would walmart ever boast the fact that it employs only “Non-Union” workers? I don’t think so.